Why GDPR audits matter beyond the risk of a fine
Written by Kyle Midgley
Kyle Midgley explains why GDPR audits should look beyond fines, testing everyday data protection practices and turning findings into clear, prioritised improvements.
“How likely are we to get fined?”
It is a question that comes up when organisations consider investing in data protection. I understand why. Budgets are limited, and businesses need to decide where to focus their resources.
But the likelihood of enforcement cannot be the only measure of whether something deserves attention. Having worked in food quality and compliance before moving into data protection auditing, I would not consider a food safety check unnecessary simply because an inspector was unlikely to visit. I take the same view on protecting personal information.
A phrase from my previous workplace has stayed with me:
“Do the right thing, even when no one is watching.”
We hold information about people who trust us to handle it responsibly. That responsibility exists whether or not someone is checking.
What happens in practice matters
An organisation may have a retention schedule, but can it demonstrate that records are actually deleted? It may have a privacy notice, but does it accurately explain what happens to people’s information?
These arrangements can become a tick-box exercise. I try to put myself in the individual’s shoes: would I understand what my information is used for, the lawful basis and how long it is kept? How would I feel if sensitive information about me was exposed in a breach when it should already have been deleted?
International transfers are another recurring issue. When I ask whether an organisation transfers personal data outside the UK, “no” is a common answer. My next questions are about its processors: who are they, where do they store information, and where can their support teams access it? What due diligence has been undertaken?
Using a processor does not remove the controller’s responsibility for how that information is handled. Until those arrangements have been checked, the organisation may not have enough information to answer confidently.
The same applies to breach management. Assigning responsibility and writing a procedure are useful steps. But would staff recognise a potential breach? Would they know who to contact and how quickly to act? Do they understand that all personal data breaches must be recorded, even those that do not require notification to the ICO?
These are the kinds of questions that make an audit useful.
Keeping pace with change
As organisations adopt AI and introduce new systems, their use of personal information can change quickly. Existing policies and assessments may no longer reflect what staff and technology are doing.
Organisations need to understand whether their safeguards remain appropriate and operate effectively as working practices change.
An independent view
Recurring findings in my audit work include incomplete processing records, gaps in evidence supporting lawful processing, inconsistent implementation of retention periods and insufficient processor oversight.
These weaknesses can exist alongside knowledgeable staff and effective controls. An audit should recognise what works while establishing where improvement is needed.
An independent auditor brings a fresh perspective, challenges assumptions and follows the evidence. My approach combines document review with discussions, operational evidence and testing where appropriate, to establish whether arrangements on paper reflect everyday practice.
A practical route to improvement
A useful report should explain the evidence, provide a supported assurance opinion and turn findings into clear, prioritised actions. This gives management a firmer basis for deciding what needs attention and where to commit resources.
The question I would encourage organisations to ask is: “How do we know our data protection arrangements are working?”
A GDPR audit from Data Protection People helps you answer that question. If you are unsure whether your arrangements reflect everyday practice, speak to us about a GDPR audit.